Football transfers have always been a hot topic, with clubs spending astronomical sums to secure the services of top players. Over the years, we’ve seen record-breaking deals that have reshaped the sport, but not all of them have lived up to the hype. In this post, we’ll take a closer look at some of football’s most expensive transfers and evaluate whether they were worth the investment.
1. Neymar to Paris Saint-Germain (€222 million, 2017)
The most expensive transfer in football history, Neymar’s move from Barcelona to PSG sent shockwaves through the sport. While Neymar has delivered moments of brilliance, injuries and off-field controversies have limited his impact. PSG’s ultimate goal—winning the UEFA Champions League—remains unfulfilled.
Verdict: Mixed. Neymar brought star power, but the return on investment has been questionable.
2. Kylian Mbappé to Paris Saint-Germain (€180 million, 2018)
Initially a loan deal that turned permanent, Mbappé’s transfer from Monaco to PSG has been a resounding success. The French forward has consistently been one of the best players in the world, scoring goals at an incredible rate and leading PSG to multiple domestic titles.
Verdict: Worth it. Mbappé has been a game-changer for PSG.
3. Philippe Coutinho to Barcelona (€160 million, 2018)
Barcelona hoped Coutinho would fill the void left by Neymar, but the Brazilian struggled to adapt to the team’s style. After a series of underwhelming performances, he was loaned out to Bayern Munich, where he ironically won the Champions League against Barcelona.
Verdict: Not worth it. One of the biggest transfer flops in recent history.
4. João Félix to Atlético Madrid (€126 million, 2019)
Atlético Madrid broke the bank to sign the Portuguese wonderkid from Benfica. While Félix has shown flashes of brilliance, he has struggled to consistently perform under Diego Simeone’s defensive system.
Verdict: Too early to tell, but so far, the return has been underwhelming.
5. Antoine Griezmann to Barcelona (€120 million, 2019)
Griezmann’s move from Atlético Madrid to Barcelona was highly anticipated, but he failed to replicate his form at Camp Nou. After two underwhelming seasons, he returned to Atlético on loan.
Verdict: Not worth it. A costly misstep for Barcelona.
6. Jack Grealish to Manchester City (€117 million, 2021)
Grealish became the most expensive British player when he joined Manchester City from Aston Villa. While he has contributed to City’s success, including a historic treble in 2023, his individual performances have been inconsistent.
Verdict: Partially worth it. His role in the team’s success justifies the fee, but more is expected.
7. Romelu Lukaku to Chelsea (€115 million, 2021)
Lukaku’s return to Chelsea was supposed to solve their striker woes, but the Belgian struggled to adapt and was loaned back to Inter Milan after just one season.
Verdict: Not worth it. A costly mistake for Chelsea.
8. Paul Pogba to Manchester United (€105 million, 2016)
Pogba’s return to Manchester United was met with great excitement, but his time at Old Trafford was marred by inconsistency and injuries. Despite moments of brilliance, he failed to live up to the price tag.
Verdict: Not worth it. A disappointing transfer for United.
9. Cristiano Ronaldo to Juventus (€100 million, 2018)
Ronaldo’s move to Juventus was a statement signing, and he delivered on the pitch with over 100 goals in three seasons. However, Juventus failed to win the Champions League, which was the primary goal.
Verdict: Partially worth it. Ronaldo’s individual success was undeniable, but the team’s failure to achieve its ultimate goal makes this a mixed bag.
10. Eden Hazard to Real Madrid (€100 million, 2019)
Hazard’s move to Real Madrid was supposed to be the start of a new era, but injuries and poor form turned it into a nightmare. He struggled to make an impact and was eventually released.
Verdict: Not worth it. One of the biggest transfer flops in football history.
Conclusion
While some expensive transfers have paid off handsomely, others have been costly mistakes. Factors like player fit, team dynamics, and injuries play a huge role in determining the success of a transfer. As clubs continue to break the bank for top talent, the question remains: is the risk worth the reward?
What do you think? Which transfer do you consider the best or worst? Share your thoughts in the comments below!
Don’t forget to subscribe for more football insights and analysis!
